22

Can we have a functionality that will insert corresponding line immediately:

[![enter image description here][1]][1]

and allow us to continue editing of a question or an answer while actual image will be loaded in the background? And only after this process is completed, this functionality will add another line:

[2]: https://i.stack.imgur.com/2KWwr.png

"silently" in the end of text being edited without interrupting the work of the editor?

Recently (about 6 months into the past) something has permanently gone really bad and:

  • at least for my location (southern Poland),
  • even though I am on 600/60 Mbit cable connection,

uploading image as small as 5 kBytes takes approx. 5-10 seconds. Not mentioning really big images which upload to imgur can last 30+ seconds.

Currently image loader covers the whole editor and prevents edit from being continued. So each such upload means at least 15-30 seconds of break in editing the content. This is a very counter-productive as far as I know (correct me if I am wrong).

EDIT (6 July 2020): My main ISP upgraded my line and subscription plan to up to 900/90 Mbps and I was also playing around with quite a few other ISP providers and testing this in various geographical locations and... nothing has changed for past 9 months.

Uploading even a tiny image takes at least 10 seconds and editing is totally blocked during that. If I have a question or answer that includes three or more images then uploading all of them will most likely take more time in total than actually writing an post (I tend to keep things short).

We urgently need a feature of uploading images in background without blocking an editor in the same time.

Please, do not post answers and comments like "hmm... works for me" or "I upload images with a snap of fingers". I don't discuss internet speed here. I discuss the lack of feature of background images upload in the entire SE.

7
  • 1
    I've been wondering about this for a while. It makes repairing third party image hosts a pain to do efficiently. – Zoe the 1337 Princess Oct 20 '19 at 11:17
  • Try speedtest.net - I can't find a site in Poland but I can find one in the neighboring country: "Mobile TeleSystems JLLC Minsk" that works at the expected speed. Searching through some Forums the common factors seemed to be the browser / computer configuration. Ask a friend nearby how it is for them. – Rob Oct 20 '19 at 14:12
  • My experience is that this speed does not depend very much much on the location. California, Germany, Vietnam and India have all a very comparable (and really annoyingly long) wait time. (Only China is different, behind the Great Firewall it does not make much sense to use imgur, so you also do not have to wait. ;-) – user603947 Oct 20 '19 at 22:49
  • @Rob Can speedtest.net test my communication directly between my computer and SE / imgur? I doubt this. I am using this service on daily basis and it shows me something around half of network operator promised values -- i.e. around 300/30. When I copy files between my computer and my remote backup, I am getting a true speeds (in itself slow FTP protocol) of 8-12 MB/s (not MBps!), so it is certainly an issue in imgur or somewhere between me and imgur. – trejder Oct 21 '19 at 6:18
  • In the event that it's none of those three things your course of action is to contact imgur to ask why it's so slow. --- As far as implementation goes it's technically possible, and links can be numbered live and updated in correct order as you add new links during the upload. Should the background upload fail that would need to be detected, a means to signal SE (and you) be agreed upon, and the link deleted from underfoot (exactly how the nature of the error is to be explained remains to be determined). The UI for uploading was recently updated, another change may not be soon. – Rob Oct 21 '19 at 6:33
  • @Ollie I could write it down on a piece of paper or stop editing at all. That's not a point. I don't want to use "3rd party solution", because main editor forces me to wait 10 seconds during each image upload. – trejder Jul 8 '20 at 19:21
  • An update: most of the slowness wasn't coming from upload speed, but because Imgur's image processing was slow. This has been fixed, and it only now takes 1-2 seconds after clicking the upload button to image insertion. I still think this should be implemented, though, for users with slow upload speeds. – Sonic the Curiouser Hedgehog Nov 21 '20 at 2:21
4

This is now possible with the new Stacks Editor (currently an alpha test). Look below:

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .