16

Ordinarily, users with 15k+ reputation can protect questions that are at least 24 hours old, and have at least one answer from a user with less than 10 reputation.

However, I'm unable to protect this question, which satisfies both of these criteria: the "protect" button doesn't show up. After eliminating other potential causes, such as:

  • the one answer from a <10 rep user being not from a new user, but from an established user who is suspended: protection should still be possible in this case
  • the fact that the question has an active bounty: I've protected questions with bounties before with no problem, and I've only had 15k+ reputation (or even a registered account) after the current criteria were set

...I believe the only remaining reason is the fact that a moderator has disabled commenting. Since, internally, this is still treated as a lock, and locked questions can't ordinarily be answered or protected, the "protect" option doesn't show.

Can it please be made possible for 15k+ users to protect questions on which a moderator has disabled commenting?

Update: This also applies for the "unprotect" option as well: there are no restrictions on unprotecting, so the only possible reason why the "unprotect" option isn't showing up is because the question is comment-locked.

6

Thanks for the report! I made sure the protected and locked notices played well together, but completely forgot about the menu links.

This is now fixed.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .