7

Recently I looked at situations where the PostNotices table shows a different OwnerUserId and DeletionUserId. This was based on Glorfindel's advice, who suggested this as a way to find bounties which were cancelled (refunded) by a moderator: When a bounty is returned by moderator, is this shown in the revision history (timeline, SEDE)?

I have run the following query on Mathematics: https://data.stackexchange.com/math/query/1236765/bounties-cancelled-by-moderators When looking in columns with users, sometimes the user shown there an the end of a bounty (i.e., the user who removed the notice) isn't a moderator. Moreover, in those instance the timeline the revision history show the same user - which is different from the information obtained from PostNotices table. In order to make them easier to find, here is a query which is restricted to these instances. The posts in question are: 3465251, 3354783, 2783577, 236640, 2651720, 979747.

I did not find such instances on other sites. (I have to admit that I did not look for many of them. Moreover, it is much easier to notice this on a site I am familiar with, since I know who are present and past moderators.)

I have tagged this as . If I simply overlooked something, I have no problem with changing the tag to .

EDIT: A moderator on Mathematics Stack Exchange confirmed in chat that some merges have been done.

  • 1
    Maybe those were users merged during the bounty period? I see that is the same guess @Glorfindel made in SEDE chat ... – rene May 10 at 6:41
  • 1
    Since the previous comment mentions a discussion in chat about this, I will also include a link: chat.meta.stackexchange.com/rooms/1223/conversation/… – Martin May 10 at 6:55
  • The posts you link here show that an answer was chosen in their timeline... – Luuklag May 10 at 7:20
  • @Luuklag That's exactly the point. For example, timeline of this post shows all bounty-related actions (start/end, notice added/removed) associated with the user Yannic Muller. However, the linked SEDE query shows two different user ids (in OwnerUserId and DeletionUserId). – Martin May 10 at 7:23
  • 2
    The Ids shown in SEDE are indeed deleted user Ids from user merges, though I have no idea where they're coming from. It's possible they just aren't updated on merge because they don't get displayed anywhere and no one has ever noticed. – animuson May 10 at 14:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .