I noticed a badge (Talkative) and it seemed to me I should have been awarded it. Especially, since I had been awarded a similar Hat (Verified) during Winter/Summer Bash 2022.
The talkative badge is documented as needing 10 or more messages and at least one of them having been starred.
I did some digging with a SEDE query, that confirms I have never been awarded it.
From the reports of my recent chat activity, I compiled a list of all the rooms I've participated with 10 or more posts and 1 or more stars:
|Winter / Summer Bash 2022||Chat.SE pointing to Meta.SE||830 since 12/16/22||27 on 23 messages|
|Winter/Summer Bash Starring room||Chat.SE pointing to Meta.SE||107 since 12/16/22||53 on 42 messages|
|Risner’s Tiny Hut||Chat.SE using parents||47 since 1/1/23||15 on 15 messages|
|Risner's Magnificent Mansion||Chat.SE pointing to SO||367 since 12/21/22||8 on 5 messages|
|Winter Bash 2022||Chat.SE pointing to SO||11 since 12/16/22||10 on 10 messages|
Per conversations with Catija and others, it seems that will only be awarded on chat profiles created on one of the following:
- Chat rooms made on chat.stackoverflow.com.
- Chat rooms made on chat.meta.stackexchange.com.
- Chat rooms made on chat.stackexchange.com chosing a non-meta primary site other than SO or Meta.SE.