I thought that it meant that I should get 400 upvotes (which equals to 4000 points) only for my answers to questions which weren't marked as community wiki.

But I've just seen this user with reputation a little bigger than 4000, who has a silver badge in the tag. He couldn't have earned the 4k for the answers only (I didn't count, but he earned at least 500 points for asking questions and at least 300 for answers to questions without the Java tag).

So, how are these 400 upvotes calculated?


2 Answers 2


The badge undoubtedly counts upvotes received above and beyond the rep cap. Thus, rep cannot be used as reliable gauge to determine a person's eligibility for silver tag badges.

(I was apparently wrong in the original about CW posts and questions. The badge does explicitly state that it is for answers only.)

  • 6
    Upvotes on CW posts aren't counted in the total, and neither are question upvotes. Commented Mar 14, 2010 at 21:48
  • The important point here is beyond the repcap votes on answers do count. 189 answers in 24 days implies 8ish answers a day. If he's averaging +3 on them he's already over the rep cap... Commented Mar 14, 2010 at 22:42

The user could have lost reputation, either by being downvoted, or spending it on bounties.

  • 4
    From the rep graph, he spent 200 on a bounty. Commented Mar 14, 2010 at 22:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .