Meta Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for meta-discussion of the Stack Exchange family of Q&A websites. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I added a comment to the first answer on this question, voted it down and won an Organizer badge?
However I didn't retag it as the description of the badge says. I think this is a bug
So this is probably a bug, what should I do?
EDIT: So did anyone found out why I won this badge?
Did the previous user retag the question and when I voted down I got the badge on his behalf?
Took a while but I think that I've figured out the real bug. As can be seen here:
You got the badge for totally different question (10K only) than what you thought and the badge was awarded as a result of you deleting the question. Your other actions (commenting, downvoting) are totally irrelevant, you could also blame the coffee you were drinking. ;-)
In that question revisions I do see one old revision where you changed tags but as part of bigger edit, so it did not count as "retag" at the time.
As far as I can tell, this is an edge case where the delete process trigger kind of "badge recalculate" task that wrongly identifies edits that change tags (but not only tags) as retag.
This appears to be a definite bug considering you have less than 250 rep. You can't even retag normal questions (though you can edit CWs) and I looked at your activity history(along with @Jon) and did not find any retagging.
This will be fixed in an upcoming build, with an overhaul of the badge code. I'm going through each query and caught a few edge cases and bugs here and there. We're fixing them along the way, this one included.
Sometimes it takes a few minutes for badges to show up. It is likely that you previously re-tagged a question.
