I got a bug when logging in for the first time on appstack and trying to associate my account with my other accounts on the trilogy site. I am using Google Open ID; then I say 'OK' on the Google page to access my credentials; then I am back on the appstack page and I click 'Create Account' and that causes an error ('This is our fault... bla bla').

So I click the login again, Google Open ID again and that logs me in directly. So clearly part of the user creation process worked. However, I did get 'user1021' instead of my normal name shown at the top of my page.

So I came here to post the bug, but I had never registered for this site either, so I go through the same process of account creation and lo-and-behold, I experience the exact same issue! (I get user name 'user147381' this time).

So it looks like a reproductible bug and I even think I know the cause. On StackOverflow, my username is 'AD', 2-letter, that's it. When I try to edit my profile on AppStack, I get an error message when I put in 'AD': 'Display name must be at least 3 characters'.

That's it... I sure hope I can keep my 'AD' name on StackOverflow!

Edit: I can replicate the buggy behavior at will with the 'Copy my profile from StackOverflow' button.


A new rule was implemented which requires at least 3 letters in the username. See Jeff's post here.

The most relevant quote is the following:

However, users who have an existing 2 character name may retain it, but will be unable to copy their profile from site to site until they make their username at least 3 characters.

The error in account creation is probably a result of the automatic account association that was also recently implemented. Since that automatically attempts to copy the profile, it would identically cause an error.

  • 1
    Yes, this all makes sense. However, there should be a clear error message instead of the unknown error page. – ADB May 24 '10 at 12:55

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .