Say I'm considering a proposal for Blender 3D modelling software - but is that too narrow a subject? Should the site be for 3D Modelling, and not one specific package? How do you determine the granularity of a site proposal?
Update - I realize that I'm taking my life in my hands, by disagreeing with people who have more karma than I'll ever see, but... :) I've read the comment-links (which are good, thanks), but I don't see how this is a duplicate Question.
Joel asked a very general Question, "how to make a successful proposal" - and then gave four distinct Answers, one of which was pick the right scope.
My question was, How do I pick the right scope for a proposal? Which was more specific, and, IMHO, not the same as his Question at all...
Yes, I now see that he (sort of) answered my Question, but it certainly wasn't in response to the same Question. Aren't Q/A supposed to be more single-Question/multiple competing Answers, also? Should his Answers be split into four Questions?