I have committed a proposal yesterday, I noticed its increased 1%

But according to this, and Jeff's email, I uncommited today, it went down from 3% to 1%, so it cost -2%

Does it fair?


1 Answer 1


I'm guessing it's simply a case of the percentage complete being rounded to the nearest percent when it gets displayed.

Eg. Let's say you're "worth" 1.3% and you commit to the proposal while it's at exactly 1% complete. This will push it up to 2.3%, which will be displayed as 2%. Then as other commiters continue joining, the percentage will keep going up little by little. Lets say it got to 2.7% when you decided to leave, it would have been displayed as 3%, but when you left it would have dropped to 1.4%, which would be displayed as 1% giving the appearance of a 2% drop.

So it just looks like it went up 1% & then down 2%, when it really just went up & down 1.3%.

  • 5
    also.. the conspiracy! Jun 16, 2010 at 5:20
  • @Jeff - This is clearly just the plausible sounding yet not quite as satisfying "swamp gas & weather balloons" cover up story, as required for any good conspiracy theory.
    – Alconja
    Jun 16, 2010 at 6:14

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .