I find it very hard to sometimes type nicks that have characters that I don't have on my keyboard or have very long names.
It's a convinience feature, makes the comments easier to use and also helps commenting on a big thread.
It shouldn't be very hard to implement.
Parhaps adding a reply button that will just add the nickname to your comment instead will do. Is there a reason not to implement such features?


4 Answers 4


There's are userscripts over at StackApps that do autocomplete and add a reply link

(StackApps is a sister site for userscripts and apps that use the api or add functionality to the sites.)


tbh I just copy/paste - but in theory it would be possible to spot them at the client with regex and offer a reply button via jQuery.

knowing this site, someone will have a grease-monkey script in 5, 4, 3....

  • Fun fact: did you know that when B. Smith comments, followed by B. Gates, using @B. Smith actually notifies the latter? One would need to remove the spaces in the @mention to avoid that.
    – Arjan
    Commented Aug 14, 2011 at 10:21

If you're using Firefox or Chrome, there's a Greasemonkey script over here to add a reply button in comments.

  • The link is now dead for some reason :/
    – the_drow
    Commented Mar 2, 2011 at 20:44

Long names and non-keyboard characters can both be handled by the current comment system.

If a name is too long, all you need to do is use the shortest unique string of at least 3 characters. The system handles the rest for you. So instead of trying to type out (picking random person with a decently lengthed name...) Juan Manuel Formoso's full name, I can get away with @jua, adding extra letters if I need to ensure that he specifically gets the reply.

For non-keyboard characters, if the name is something like Péter Török, you can get away with @Peter. Now, if you're talking about someone who isn't even using this alphabet of letters for their display name, then unfortunately you'll have to rely on copy/paste. The number of users for whom this is the case, however, is small.

This should mitigate the majority of problems with names that are too long or you lack the proper keyboard to type. The feature requests for auto-completion or a reply button are both previously discussed.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .