Based on the comment on this answer from Joel S., I'm curious if a proposal can be reversed through the phases.

So for example, in the case being discussed in that question, say a bunch of sockpuppets are in on a proposal, but it's only discovered later on. Instead of closing, would the proposal be "un-committed" (that's a bad term because it means something else) from the current phase and moved to the previous phase?

1 Answer 1


There's no explicit "un-commit" or "un-beta" function behind the scenes in Area 51.

Over time, we are going to be studying and refining what constitutes "advancing a successful site" and closing less successful ones. If we discover a flaw in the process, we'll make adjustments. If there is a fixable problem with the site, we'll go back and fix it (hopefully to a more successful launch later).

Our primary goal is to create successful sites. It's not like we're going to spite ourselves if something goes wrong along the way. But nobody knows what types of problems could arise, much less how we are going to handle these hypothetical glitches. But we'll handle them.

  • I was just curious about what functions and processes are available to moderators. Thanks for the explanation!
    – Jon Seigel
    Jun 29, 2010 at 12:26

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .