I know that finding the right granularity for a proposal is tough. I'm wondering if the Powers-that-be have any information on how many proposals have changed (presumably to be wider in scope), and thereby increased their number of followers?

Personally, after I proposed a Blender software site, it didn't do so hot - so I widened the scope to all 3D modelling software, and it did - slightly better... :)


We're still discussing how to deal with merging smaller proposals at this point.

My idea was if enough high rep (2k) users vote for a merge then every committer is emailed and has to say yea or nay to the merge. If at least, say 50 percent, on each side agree this is a valid merge then we merge them.

I think the committers have to agree as only they have the required domain knowledge to determine if this is a valid merge or not.

  • 1
    What if the smaller proposal is a duplicate? area51.stackexchange.com/proposals/10961/weight-loss Can these be merged by a moderator? – Jon Seigel Jul 10 '10 at 8:13
  • 1
    I really don't think it takes much domain knowledge to know that barefoot running is a very limited subset of running, despite the proposer's claim that it's "specialized enough to merit its own discussion." But hey, I don't run barefoot, I could be wrong... :) – John C Jul 10 '10 at 14:05

I have an example of the inverse: my writing proposal was originally called "Books and Writing", but the audience seemed to be very different, so I dropped the "books" part and it got to commitment phase anyway.

Then a books proposal was created to cover what it was left out there (this one still needs more followers though).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .