2008: Resharper vs. CodeRush This Question has 63 votes and 18 answers, the top answer has 74 votes. It contains a useful comparison of two competing products and is pretty even-handed.
https://stackoverflow.com/questions/6693354/2011-resharper-vs-coderush This question is closed as "not constructive".
What's the deal here? This seems like a useful and valuable question in general, and, as both products are evolving, it seems fair to ask for a re-evaluation after 3 years.