Questions tagged [edits]
For questions about the process of editing, how edits work, and other general inquiries about the edit system.
1,171
questions
1124
votes
32
answers
121k
views
Should 'Hi', 'thanks', taglines, and salutations be removed from posts?
I edit a lot of posts every day. I often run across posts with 'Hi' and 'Thanks' on the top and the bottom of the post respectively. I also run across things like:
--User
Should these items be ...
860
votes
21
answers
18k
views
Can we have the ability to retract a close vote before it closes?
Sometimes you vote to close something and the OP then changes it to fix the issue or issues. You can't take a close vote back though. It would be nice if you could.
With the new Duplicate close ...
- 48.3k
102
votes
1
answer
21k
views
How does editing work?
It is possible for users to edit an existing post.
How do edits work?
Who may edit a question or answer?
How can you tell what has been changed between edits?
For more information, see "Why can ...
886
votes
21
answers
14k
views
Allow an edit to notify downvoters: "I think I've fixed the issue now - please check"
To me, a downvote usually indicates a problem with an answer. When I downvote it's to mark the answer as having a problem, not the person. If the answer is fixed, I want to remove that downvote - but ...
- 93.8k
170
votes
7
answers
4k
views
Are we discouraged from fixing typos and misspellings on Stack Exchange sites?
I just attempted to fix a typo on a question on cooking.stackexchange.com and saw this
Oops! Your edit couldn't be submitted because:
Your edit summary must be at least 10 characters
This ...
- 8,910
422
votes
5
answers
17k
views
What is a 'rollback'?
What is a 'rollback' on Stack Exchange sites? I have seen this mentioned but I do not understand the term.
Please note: this question has been locked as it was used as a sandbox for performing ...
357
votes
6
answers
5k
views
Reject an already-approved suggested edit when rolling it back
The content of this post has been sanitized in response to anonymous feedback that the formatting was making it completely unreadable by assistive technology (AT). I strongly value making content ...
- 48.6k
115
votes
8
answers
2k
views
Could we have the ability to mark a change as minor in questions or answers?
It would be nice to allow users to mark a change in an answer (or question) as minor (e.g. for a simple spelling or grammar correction). A change marked as minor wouldn't push the question on top of ...
- 3,314
220
votes
3
answers
9k
views
What is the etiquette for modifying posts?
I'm getting pretty close to the reputation where I can start to edit others' posts, and I'm wondering what the etiquette for when (and when not) to do so.
I figure that I should edit in the following ...
144
votes
8
answers
2k
views
Can we disable automatic community wiki conversion for answer edits?
Currently, if a user edits their answer more than a certain number of times, that answer is automatically converted by the system to community wiki status. This trips up many well-meaning and active ...
- 60.7k
159
votes
3
answers
3k
views
Should spam posts be edited?
I noticed that the posts of the recent spam surge on Ask Ubuntu were all edited by community members into something like
EDITED - REMOVED SPAM ANSWER
or similar.
While I understand why the users ...
- 187k
80
votes
1
answer
3k
views
When is "EDIT"/"UPDATE" appropriate in a post?
I often see questions edited into this form:
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet blah blah blah paragraph paragraph original question.
UPDATE: The Lorem disappeared and left this message: "new ...
- 4,463
97
votes
11
answers
2k
views
Is losing privileges after placing bounty OK?
My rep went over 2,000 today which meant I could edit other people's posts. Great! Then I added a bounty to a previous question, which brought me back down to 1,984...and I can no longer edit other ...
- 37.1k
69
votes
3
answers
3k
views
What should I keep out of my posts and titles?
I've recently been editing out things such as "hope this helps" and "good luck" from posts and was wondering if that crosses the imaginary line that seems to not exist in the scattered mess of ...
58
votes
8
answers
2k
views
How far can I refactor the code in someone else's question? [closed]
With a growing number of more or less inexperienced programmers on Stack Overflow, it is frequent to see the questions containing code not only badly formatted, but also badly written. While editing a ...
- 1,106
20
votes
3
answers
2k
views
Is there an editing 'grace period' on answers after they have been posted? [duplicate]
I answered a question (not 10 minutes ago), after about 3 minutes I decided to edit my own post with more details. When I was done editing (took me about 20 seconds to edit), I noticed there were 2 ...
174
votes
10
answers
2k
views
Make first draft of a new answer part of the permanent revision history
I find the grace period can lend itself to some unscrupulous behavior on popular tags. I've often seen an earlier, minimalist answer be updated within the first 5 minutes, and incorporate something ...
Aaron BertrandStaff
- 42.9k
101
votes
8
answers
851
views
Notify us when the question has been edited after posting an answer
Consider this situation. I post a legitimate and correct answer to a question and receive a few upvotes. Then the OP realizes that's not what they wanted to ask, and significantly rewrites the ...
- 4,894
115
votes
5
answers
7k
views
How can I cancel an edit I made on another user's question or answer?
Edits made by users who do not have edit privileges are placed in a queue until it is peer reviewed.
E.g., I edited someone else's answer. but changed my mind. If I'd edited my own question/answer, ...
- 1,452
107
votes
7
answers
1k
views
Let me reward a good edit on my question/answer
Often an edit to one of my questions or answers will make it a lot better. The edit can constitute more to the site than someone posting another answer or comment.
Some users make quite a lot of good ...
- 27.5k
73
votes
7
answers
13k
views
Is there a way to disable the hotkeys?
I navigate with Ctrl+n,p,f,b (readline/Emacs keys), so that I don't have to move my hands too much and get RSI again. Is there a way to disable Ctrl+b being hotkey for bold?
Note that this is not just ...
- 2,117
38
votes
1
answer
800
views
Editing a post during review doesn't show an "edit not possible" message
While reviewing First Posts on Super User, I noticed that I couldn't edit this question (see below). Clicking the "edit" link simply does nothing.
Editing is not possible for me right now ...
GlorfindelMod
- 253k
34
votes
1
answer
1k
views
No notification was received for an edit to a post
Normally, when a user edits one of my posts, I receive a notification like on the following depending on the case
User has editing privilege (click to visit revision)
Users' edit is submitted to ...
- 5,581
32
votes
4
answers
711
views
Notifications for concurrent changes when editing posts
When editing other users' posts, to reformat code or to clarify the meaning of a question, for example, I always return to the post, and refresh it, before submitting the changes to make sure that ...
- 1,035
125
votes
3
answers
1k
views
Allow non-bumping minor edits, but review them on /review
Every edit, no matter how minor, bumps a question to the frontpage of an SE site. This behaviour is important to allow the community to review edits, but it also creates significant problems when a ...
- 187k
109
votes
5
answers
1k
views
The editing race - the slackers always win
I'm having a pretty big problem with the way the editing system is working lately. I think it was a recent change, but there no longer appears to be a warning message when another user has edited the ...
- 14k
75
votes
5
answers
1k
views
Is there a way to edit a question without bumping it to the front page?
Given that the Stack Overflow trilogy is to be a resource for googlers, I usually try to go back over my questions/answers and improve them in whatever way that I can. However, I feel this may be ...
- 907
37
votes
4
answers
1k
views
Increase captcha threshold for post editing
It's a very common behavior to refine answers several times after submitting them. Most of the time, the refinement is just adding and removing several characters or words. You might notice some other ...
- 17.2k
43
votes
2
answers
667
views
Allow post editor to see @comments directed at him
There have been times when I have edited a post, left no comments, yet I have made mistakes that were pointed out simply as @comments. That's ok, but unless I actually come back to the post, I will ...
- 10.1k
23
votes
6
answers
720
views
Do we still need the Retag privilege?
Ever since suggested edits were rolled out, the Retag privilege has been a bit... Weird. You can retag questions at any rep-level, even with no rep (or account) at all - you just need a few people to ...
- 454k
18
votes
1
answer
1k
views
Abridged too far?
The new editing seems to have led to savage cuts being accepted, for example:
UTF-8 Encoding size
The links have been restored since, but as can be seen from the history, at one stage the post was ...
- 1,636
302
votes
38
answers
9k
views
How do we encourage edits to obsolete/out of date answers?
As the network ages and we have answers that are 7+ years old, we run into situations where changes in technology, etc. result in a once great answer becoming out-of-date, obsolete, or somewhat ...
- 51.5k
167
votes
14
answers
6k
views
Why are there no line numbers in the code listings?
Would it make discussing code easier if you could simply refer to a particular line or range, or am I wrong?
- 5,455
57
votes
5
answers
6k
views
Why can any user edit any other user's question or answer?
I see an "edit" link after each question and answer. So I was wondering: how come any user can change any other user's question or answer? I think the reason behind it is that each one can share their ...
34
votes
1
answer
726
views
Why does the Community User reject / approve edits? [duplicate]
I am sure this must have been asked quite a lot of times, but I am unable to find something about the guidelines the Community uses when approving / rejecting edits.
I just fixed a first question to ...
- 930
31
votes
1
answer
433
views
Question history attributed changes to me that I didn't make
I just made some minor edits to the text of this question. I didn't edit the tags at all. When I completed my edits, my edit showed as:
Now, I think those tags were present before I started my edit,...
- 15.4k
70
votes
1
answer
439
views
Let me add or change edit summary during edit window (grace period)
It often occurs to me to add an edit summary to a question-edit immediately after submitting the edit, especially if the changes aren't obvious (formatting etc.). So I:
Click "edit" again.
Fill in ...
- 2,367
5
votes
3
answers
370
views
Do you wait for edits before voting to close a question? [duplicate]
Let's say that there is a question asked in a bad manner, in a way that the question is missing. For example the user shows the code and doesn't explain very well which is the problem.
Usually ...
- 1,420
90
votes
6
answers
619
views
Display the original question beneath the answer edit form
Often when I edit one of my answers, it's because I want to better address the original question. The only problem is that I can't see the original question while I'm editing my answer!
I'd love to ...
83
votes
7
answers
2k
views
Why are trivial edits discouraged?
Looking at Edit questions and answers privilege, I find this to be a surprising requirement:
Try to make the post substantively better when you edit, not just change a single character. Tiny, trivial ...
- 9,883
63
votes
8
answers
6k
views
How aggressively should we maintain and improve very popular questions? [closed]
I was discussing this question on team chat:
How do I perform an IF...THEN in an SQL SELECT?
This question is a high value asset on the site it was posted, it already has 150k views, 120+ total votes ...
- 108k
62
votes
1
answer
1k
views
Inline Editing for Stack Exchange Sites
We have inline comment editing, inline editing of questions on Area 51, and inline re-tagging.
Can we please have inline Question and Answer editing on the Stack Exchange sites?
This has been ...
- 34.1k
94
votes
5
answers
2k
views
Kill the Retag option, use just Edit
For users with 500 < Reputation < 2000, there are two options: "retag" and "edit". It's great that the retag button is there, but it clutters up the question view. There is ...
- 50.8k
83
votes
2
answers
1k
views
Comments that fail to post start the "You can only comment every 5 seconds" timer
First: This is not about whether rate-limiting is good or bad. This is not a misunderstanding of what the "Only 1 comment allowed per 5 seconds; timer reset." message means. This is not ...
75
votes
3
answers
893
views
Notify question OP (and those who marked it a favourite) if an answer has been modified
Seriously, I had not noticed e.g. Jeff's edit here had he not also retagged my question.
- 17.8k
58
votes
8
answers
612
views
It should be possible to retag a question without bumping it to the front page
While bumps are generally good, there are niche cases where they are harmful:
I recently decided I would consolidate two tags on Stack Overflow: "openoffice" and "openoffice.org". They refer to ...
- 1,087
35
votes
4
answers
531
views
Cannot retract downvote if post has been edited within first 5 minutes of posting
Please do not close this as a duplicate unless you can remove the “status-completed” tag from the original report (because it’s obviously not been completed).
Steps to reproduce:
Have someone post ...
- 3,180
21
votes
1
answer
1k
views
When is it appropriate to edit someone else's code? [duplicate]
Possible Duplicate:
How far can I refactor someone else's code?
I see a lot of edits in queue where some well-meaning user attempts to fix OP's code. They range from minor syntax corrections, to near ...
user159834
89
votes
12
answers
2k
views
SO is too eager to turn my edited answers into Community Wiki [closed]
I like to edit my answers. To clarify, illuminate, add examples, add links, point to new information as it crops up, etc.
It's highly irritating that my effort to improve my answer turns it into a ...
- 2,391
38
votes
2
answers
1k
views
Undone edits disappear from revision history
I'm reporting the following bug per Shog9's request.
Consider the following scenario:
You edit any post on a SE site where you have edit privileges.
In a second edit within the grace period of the ...
- 22.7k