Questions tagged [moderation]
This tag is for questions dealing with moderator actions, pages, abilities or decisions.
-1
votes
2answers
98 views
Is it possible to retrieve comments deleted by a moderator?
I believe a moderator inappropriately deleted some of my comments. I have about 5K reputation there, and I am quite aware of the rules of Stack Exchange (SE) in general. My comments were ...
11
votes
1answer
95 views
Let mods flag comments (without deleting them)
There are at least two use cases when moderators really need to flag comments:
when the comments to be flagged are on their own posts (e.g. someone tells a mod to go get lost under their own post)
...
-55
votes
3answers
367 views
Stack Exchange bots, created by a moderator, are creepy and violate the CoC
A moderator has various bots that capture a bunch of comments, and these comments land up in various rooms that are in plain view of the community. I think this tactic is creepy surveillance and ...
-6
votes
0answers
79 views
Is there any procedure for impeaching a moderator? [duplicate]
They might all be perfect for all I know, but assume, for the sake of this question, that at least one moderator is for some reason generally unsatisfactory while somehow finding various ways stay ...
1
vote
0answers
33 views
When are questions which build upon each other considered duplicates?
Each Stack Exchange site caters to a mix of experts and novices. This means that some (expert) questions presuppose knowledge which is being asked about in other (novice) questions. In other words, we ...
0
votes
0answers
60 views
Want ability to flag comment for the author, rather than moderators, to notice
Occasionally, I write a comment about an answer or question; then the author makes an edit, telling me "@einpoklum: see edit" or something similar. At this point, and if my comment is not otherwise ...
12
votes
1answer
193 views
Dealing with highly sensitive personal information in a post
Recently, I found a user had posted a complete copy of their credit card magstripe in a question on Security SE. As I did not have 2k rep on that site at the time I could not force an edit to hide the ...
-9
votes
4answers
306 views
Could we extend the consequences of rude comments to the network level?
In the vein of the inclusion project, and the long list of posts about rude comments being a network wide issue...
Could we perhaps extend the consequences of rude comments to the network level?
...
5
votes
2answers
119 views
Do we avoid questions about current events that have a limited life?
RPG Stack Exchange, along with a few other older sites, have this bullet point in our on-topic FAQ:
We don't want the information on our site to become obsolete, and so we try not to ask ...
2
votes
3answers
130 views
Does reviewing queues have any gains for me as a Stack Overflow user?
Due to my reputation on Stack Overflow, I have access to different review queues. I want to know if it will change my score/reputation or if it will only provide me some badges?
Maybe this part seems ...
8
votes
1answer
141 views
User gets chat-banned and has a bot. What happens to the bot?
Lets say a user uses chat and has a nice bot account. He legitimately earned rep on that bot and uses it to do something like evaluate math expressions in a chat room. The main user gets chatbanned ...
-6
votes
3answers
150 views
Are there different rules for comments in meta?
Some moderators on some sites are very... religious in purging any comment on any post that isn't asking for clarification or directly suggesting an improvement. These very same moderators are also ...
4
votes
1answer
80 views
Is clearing pending close votes with diamond power / gold tag badge power considered abuse? [duplicate]
Recently, I saw a moderator on Android Enthusiasts telling folks to stop voting to close a question. The mod was clever to find out that the question is actually on topic, and I added that the title ...
1
vote
1answer
107 views
Improving a Stack Exchange site, but with limited rep
I have limited reputation (less than 1k) and can only:
Ask question
Answer question
flag content
edit content
vote to close / re-open / delete questions
What else can I do in order to improve a ...
15
votes
4answers
227 views
Can moderators handle flags cast on their own content?
I was wondering what happens in the case content posted by moderators is flagged for some reason. I did some research but missed in finding some information on those cases.
It is true that, being a ...
10
votes
1answer
88 views
To what extent should a moderator investigate a flag?
If a user posts a flag, stating that a post is inflammatory, to what extent should the moderator investigate said post? Should they perform any research to confirm that there is or is not any such ...
-27
votes
3answers
274 views
Why are there private instructions for moderators, and where can we see them?
In this thread on meta.academia.se it emerged that apparently SE has "(not public) guidance to moderators" which regulates aspects such as how to behave with regard to suspensions (bans).
Is this ...
4
votes
1answer
72 views
What's the reputation minimum to see “in need of moderator intervention” questions/answers?
In Stack Exchange, there are elected moderators and moderators by reputation. But the second kind is pretty relative, as there are 9 different reputation levels for "moderation" priviledges. The flag ...
8
votes
1answer
267 views
What is the official SE process/procedure for handling abuse disclosures?
I've come to understand that on the rare occasions when someone posts an abuse disclosure to a Stack Exchange site that they're handled similarly to suicidal posts.
I've heard that there's a pretty ...
10
votes
2answers
172 views
What should I do in cases where someone blindly upvotes all posts in a tag?
I'm a moderator on Literature Stack Exchange. Today, someone flagged a case of possible serial voting. I took a look at it, and after a while, determined that it was someone who had gone through a tag ...
3
votes
1answer
38 views
Some links in emails do not work if the user is not logged in
I received an email from the moderation team. At the end it stated:
This email was sent from an unmonitored account. Do not reply
directly to this email; if you feel this message is incorrect, ...
-13
votes
1answer
73 views
Should Mods be allowed to affect questions they are related to?
I saw an instance where I voted to flag a question as off topic. Now, I am not sure, but I think that a Moderator, who might have asked/answered/commented on the question, stopped/removed(?) the flag.
...
5
votes
0answers
89 views
Can we nuke a Beta and start again?
Disclaimer
The following case-study is just my opinion and not something the Beta site in question has decided upon. I want to know whether such course of action is in theory possible before ...
-23
votes
1answer
185 views
Please give the moderators option to revoke the privilege for commenting
Doing this, the mods could stop a user from posting harmful comments, without having to resort more drastic measures (typically, giving temporary suspension).
It could serve also as an intermediary ...
-4
votes
2answers
145 views
Issue between a moderator and another user [duplicate]
I ran across a discussion recently about whether or not a moderator should be modifying the content of an answer. In this example, content was removed but the author of the answer disagreed with the ...
2
votes
1answer
131 views
Would more-heavily involved moderation bots be beneficial to Stack Exchange?
Quora has bots that do a lot of moderation, such as: auto-question-tagging, marking questions as "needs improvement," auto-question-merging, auto-answer-collapsing, and even auto-question-editing (...
-5
votes
5answers
351 views
Revisit the ruling on vulgar language?
While we merrily close questions asking about profanity and vulgar language usage on Stack Exchange as duplicates of Are expletives (cursing, swear words or vulgar language) allowed on SE sites? the ...
-12
votes
1answer
72 views
A question about the site's terms and condition and experts' viewpoint of a good question [closed]
I'm definitely going to sound rude to the experts who are actually trying to help solve problems here and I'm really sorry if you feel like I'm being disrespectful but the question is definitely not ...
13
votes
1answer
190 views
Reporting a poster planning to commit a crime
Someone just posted a (hopefully bad-taste joke) question on maximizing the damage of a school shooting to Academia.SE (since deleted). I flagged for moderator attention, but this made me wonder: Is ...
7
votes
1answer
97 views
How can we get moderator's help?
We just got a question on Academia SE (now deleted).
Obviously, it's an abusive question. At the time it happened, there was no on-site moderator available. It took 11 minutes and ten downvotes and ...
4
votes
2answers
61 views
When will a post be deleted on request?
I had a not-too-interesting answer on Stack Overflow, which was closed as duplicate after some clarification by OP.
After a day or so, OP (a ~700 reputation user) started complaining that the ...
30
votes
1answer
207 views
Chat moderation tools are insufficient for combatting star spam
Lately in The Nineteenth Byte (I know, it's always us), we've been dealing with an issue where one or more users have decided that spamming stars on every recent message is funny. While moderators and ...
14
votes
2answers
156 views
How to deal with an answer deleted and reintroduced in order to got rid of down-votes?
Here's the situation:
User provides a lengthy answer which is moderately down-voted by the community
Hoping to get rid of the doom of down-votes, user deletes the answer and introduces a new one, ...
3
votes
2answers
87 views
How to be a good reviewer?
TLDR: My thoughts about dealing with low quality content in scope of limited resources, like edits and flags.
Introduction
(this is long and perhaps little boring, so you may skip directly to The ...
-21
votes
1answer
133 views
Should users be able to downvote a moderator's action? [duplicate]
It is apparent to me that the moderators aren't really moderated. I have read many articles where moderators get overzealous in their quest to have "perfect" information.
It's like some kind of cult ...
11
votes
2answers
111 views
Should moderators be able to view deleted posts across network?
When dealing with a problematic user, it is beneficial to be able to see if they have behaved badly in general. Especially in the case of spammers, one of the greatest indicators that a post is ...
3
votes
2answers
50 views
Should I do anything about a user posting their mobile number on their About Me?
I recently visited a user's profile page and noticed that they have posted their mobile number on the "About Me" section. In my opinion, this isn't the kind of personal information that should be ...
-14
votes
1answer
171 views
Do moderators have too much power? [duplicate]
Lewis Namier once remarked:
Although we know that most men's actions are conditioned by factors other than reason, in practice we have to assume their rational character.
Does Namier’s assumption ...
271
votes
9answers
18k views
Why we don't keep public records of suspensions
Whenever the topic of a suspended user crops up, there's often confusion about what information moderators ought to share and what they should keep private. Sometimes moderators are just as unsure as ...
3
votes
0answers
64 views
Sock-puppeting and multiple accounts [duplicate]
There's a probability I've made a mistake as Stack Exchange moderator, and I just want to understand if it is indeed the case.
So I've noticed that a particular user keeps posting quite low-...
-11
votes
1answer
96 views
What can I do if some moderators delete my comments improperly? [duplicate]
There are many good moderators but the others just delete comments without any reason. At least, they don't show reasons why they delete them. It's quite unfair. Is there any rule to handle this ...
5
votes
2answers
99 views
User requests their own question be removed due to sensitive information
I have a question that has been flagged by the asker for removal because they say it contains private information that shouldn't be in the public domain. However they don't specify what elements they ...
-10
votes
3answers
162 views
May a moderator be part of something she is moderating?
I am used to moderators always staying away of issues they are moderating. They may have something to say about it but never do so at the same article/thread/question/item they are moderating.
Is ...
17
votes
2answers
147 views
What is the guidance for using “Standard Flags?”
I recently flagged a question with a custom flag reason, explaining in detail why I thought it should be closed (I don't have close privileges on the site in question). My flag was rejected with the ...
3
votes
3answers
113 views
Is it possible to ask moderators to deliberately suspend one's account for an specified time?
After seeing this profile,
This question came to my mind.
Does there exist a way to ask moderators to suspend your account up to a certain date? FOR EXAMPLE because one has become addicted and can'...
4
votes
2answers
61 views
Comments moved to chat. Why all?
A question I posted was closed as duplicate (I think it's worth reopening and in fact I'm trying to get it reopened). Also, a bunch of people made comments and a moderator moved those comments and my ...
1
vote
4answers
109 views
Should a mod reopen a closed voted question for being broad if it has an accepted answer?
I am curious to know what the protocol is for moderators if a question is closed for being broad but before it was closed the question received answers and after going back and auditing questions to ...
-7
votes
3answers
254 views
How to deal with over-aggressive moderation?
Of the various Stack Exchange communities I'm on, there is one that has rather obvious outlier moderation habits. It's a smaller community with only 3 moderators listed. At least one of these ...
3
votes
1answer
125 views
As a normal user, how should I act on posts showing a severe level of paranoia or signs of other mental problems? [duplicate]
As a normal, unprivileged user, I wonder what I should do if I encounter a post on any SE site which contains signs of severe mental health problems like paranoia or persecution mania, but not ...
2
votes
2answers
115 views
My question is still not being deleted after asking for moderator intervention
I have a question on Workplace that I regretted posting almost immediately afterwards. People were researching my background and making critical remarks about my programming skill. It's not something ...
