Questions tagged [site-evaluation]

Community self-evaluations was an answer quality evaluation process that took place on some Stack Exchange sites from 2012 to 2015.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
8
votes
0answers
64 views

Admin > Site Self-Eval Stats claims that there will be more site self-evals in the future

The Admin > Site Self-Eval Stats screen (/admin/review/site-eval-stats - diamond-only) claims that a new site self-eval will be spawned six months after the previous one ended. For example, on Anime....
9
votes
2answers
85 views

Site health dashboard (for graduated and beta sites alike)

Related: How were the guidelines for a healthy site determined Shutting down recurring community self-evaluations Executive summary Could the devs please make a weekly updatable dashboard with ...
119
votes
4answers
4k views

Shutting down recurring community self-evaluations

We've been talking a lot about the efficacy of community self-evaluations lately, both internally on the Community Team and out in the open on meta. Lots of ideas were tossed around, but the ...
103
votes
15answers
6k views

Should introspection be encouraged in light of the new standards for graduation?

Summary With the introduction of new, simplified graduation requirements, we're preparing to shut down the venerable Community Eval review process. Years of waning participation, combined with a ...
7
votes
1answer
74 views

On site self evaluations, is it OK to answer the questions before the review queue is closed?

Related to this question (about fixing spelling errors in nominated questions), but about actually answering one or more of the questions. It seems that this kind of defeats the purpose of a quality ...
4
votes
1answer
70 views

Site Self-Evaluation Review History interface is incomplete

Looking through the Site Self-Evaluation Review History interfaces, the names of reviewers and their review aren't shown for reviews. For example, this completed review on Movies & TV: Compare ...
27
votes
1answer
519 views

Where have the site self-evaluations gone?

Many beta sites have gone more than 3 months without a self-evaluation. Italian Language: February Computer Science: February; next one scheduled for Aug 9 Reverse Engineering: February Cryptography: ...
9
votes
0answers
37 views

Could we offer a gentle inbox reminder that self-evaluations are happening?

Notifications of elections on sites on which we are members are broadcast via the inbox. I think adding a gentle reminder of a self-evaluation in the inbox would be a worthwhile pursuit. Elections ...
4
votes
0answers
100 views

What is the purpose of the new Site Self-Evaluation Review category? [duplicate]

I spotted this Site Self-Evaluation category as a History Stack Exchange Review category today. However, it is not clear what content will appear here, or what tasks reviewers are meant to perform. ...
15
votes
2answers
131 views

Should I improve posts that are part of the site self-evaluation or wait until the evaluation ends?

On our beta-site Sustainable Living a new site self-evaluation round has just started. I am participating in the evaluation and encountered a question with several typos. I have fixed those and added ...
9
votes
1answer
108 views

Show the “review” link in the topbar on beta sites while Site Self-Evaluation review is enabled for a few days

If I don't have an Access Review Queues privilege on beta sites (i.e. less than 350 reputation), the "review" link does not appear in the top-bar. There is a review queue in beta sites named "Site ...
11
votes
1answer
130 views

Link to the Self-Evaluation review queue returns 404 at the end of the Self-Eval period

While it is correct to use a 404 response code to indicate that something that once existed is no longer found, this may cause some confusion for folks visiting a Self-Evaluation results post in a per-...
9
votes
0answers
81 views

Why do I see my own answers but not my own questions in a site self-evaluation?

I just found out experimentally that in a site evaluation, you don't get to review your own question. You do however get to review questions that you've answered. The official rationale is Since it ...
3
votes
1answer
119 views

Site review shows me a disabled “add comment” link, and tells me I need a reputation of at least 50 [duplicate]

I was looking at a question shown for the Site Self-Evaluation on English Language Learners, and noticed the "add comment" link was disabled because I needed at least 50 points of reputation. As the ...
6
votes
1answer
124 views

Do personalized search results make site self evals less useful?

Google search results vary significantly depending on your previous browsing history, you past searches and many other factors. The users' who actually perform the site evals will generally be the ...
2
votes
1answer
129 views

Movies and TV Site Self-Evaluation review queue not giving 10 question

In Movies & TV beta Site Self-Evaluation review queue Apr 2013 , i only got 7 question. And as i know everybody gets 10 question. I didn't even skipped any question. So what is the problem with ...
19
votes
1answer
262 views

Can we see the results of our community evaluation?

Back when beta evaluations were conducted by meta post, people could see how other members of the community felt about the site. Each question under review had a net score indicating it was ...
12
votes
0answers
114 views

Can we inform users that the choices they make when filling out a community evaluation will be visible?

Looking at the text that greets a new community evaluation session, I see no mention of whether the votes a uses casts (Excellent, Satisfactory, Needs Improvement) will be kept confidential or made ...
5
votes
1answer
110 views

Can I only review 10 questions in a community evaluation?

Yesterday several Stack Exchange sites I visit began a community evaluation. I reviewed 10 questions and answers on each of two sites, Unix & Linux and IT Security. Today, when I returned, I see ...
14
votes
1answer
372 views

“Community Evaluation” on established sites

If the Community Evaluation review queue is only for beta sites to help determine if/when the site is ready for graduation (so it says in the answer to What are the review queues, and how do they work?...
10
votes
2answers
196 views

Which questions need Community Evaluaton?

Which questions need Community Evaluation? What's the criteria to be added to the review queue for Community Evaluation? What is done if a review gets the result Needs Improvement or Satisfactory?
19
votes
2answers
288 views

Can we have comments and/or separate Q and A voting for the new community eval?

I noticed the new community eval queue on Chem. I like the concept, but I feel that is should allow for separate voting for the Q and As: Currently, the categories talk of the combined quality of the ...
32
votes
5answers
692 views

Strategies for handling beta community quality evaluations

Periodically, the Community Team will evaluate the quality of a beta site. In addition to examining general site traffic stats and Meta activity, we check the content quality by selecting 10 random ...