Skip to main content
436 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

I'm on board with the idea of reminding people to be considerate to those who are new to the site, but I think there's a piece missing. The new UI element encourages established users to help the new ...
BJ Myers's user avatar
  • 3,652
370 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

This really isn't adding new information. Mostly because showing rep provides this information already. When you see someone with very little rep, the odds of them being within a few days old are ...
Servy's user avatar
  • 76k
242 votes
Accepted

What about the community is "toxic" to new users?

There are a few different reasons that people perceive Stack Overflow - and, to a lesser extent, the other Stack Exchange sites - as toxic. Let's get into a few of them. The most major reason, in my ...
Mithical's user avatar
  • 80.7k
174 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Noob alert! Remember to put on your kid gloves! Seriously? I don't like this at all. Yes, some people are new to the site. Yes, we should know that they may not understand all the rules. But no, we ...
forest distrusts StackExchange's user avatar
121 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Ouch. Whatever made you think this is a good idea? Well, ok, I can see how it would be appealing. But have you considered the potential downsides from labeling new users with a target marked “NOOB”? ...
Gilles 'SO- stop being evil''s user avatar
99 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Okay - why does it matter if the user is a new contributor or new to a technology when they're asking a question? I feel like this particular aspect is being ignored; it should not matter in the ...
Makoto's user avatar
  • 58.3k
99 votes

What about the community is "toxic" to new users?

In the eyes of the newbies: Downvotes are considered toxic. Closure of a question is considered super toxic. Any comment trying to explain any of the above is considered toxic. The Welcome Wagon ...
Shadow Wizard Love Zelda's user avatar
80 votes
Accepted

Usability issues for first-time Stack Exchange users - a micro-study

Good job! This is awesome. There's a lot of useful observations here, but here are a few I'd highlight specifically: The default copy in the hero is kinda goofy. It has that, "No charge - EVER. Enter ...
Jaydles's user avatar
  • 52.7k
80 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Will new users also see this mini-banner on their own posts? I could imagine someone being slightly perturbed by seeing a "welcome to the site" type comment when they've been around for 6 days or so. ...
Rand al'Thor's user avatar
  • 33.4k
72 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Good UI design does not overwhelm users with redundant information. Repeating that new user status three times on a single page is a tad redundant. None of the regular contributors are completely ...
HBruijn's user avatar
  • 897
70 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

This feature is rude and unwelcoming. You're not singling out behaviors that need to change. You're dropping a blanket accusation of poor behavior on everyone. The very idea that everyone needs this ...
jpmc26's user avatar
  • 5,569
60 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

I think that some of these, particularly the notification in the answer box, is too intrusive. The tag on the user's infobox is livable. The tag on the comment box is odd, but maybe acceptable. But ...
Nicol Bolas's user avatar
  • 33.4k
58 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

I understand your reasoning for doing this, but do not like the implementation. I also wonder if you have considered the side effects. After some time to reflect, I do not think this is a good idea in ...
David's user avatar
  • 9,494
53 votes

Introducing new user onboarding project

There's a lot to applaud here, and a lot to comment on. But I'll limit my feedback to one of each... So, first and foremost: good! Glad to see y'all tackling this. It's a thorny problem, and one that ...
Shog9's user avatar
  • 450k
49 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Nobody reads the mumbo-jumbo when signing up for a community. Nobody reads the pinned FAQ topics on top of a forum. Nobody reads the tour. Nobody previews their question before posting it. Nobody ...
CodeCaster's user avatar
  • 4,931
49 votes

What about the community is "toxic" to new users?

Those two statements seem to be generalized to the point of meaning nothing at all. Sure. But that is the thing when one tries to compile/reduce a large number of single sentence answers into "...
GhostCat's user avatar
  • 38k
48 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

For those that don't want to see this notification / banner, add the following rule to your adblocker: ##.new-contributor-indicator Or using a userstyles plugin: .new-contributor-indicator{ ...
Cerbrus's user avatar
  • 7,802
48 votes

Are we creating divisions in our quest to make new users welcome?

The problem here isn't that the site doesn't treat all people equally... It's that all people aren't equal. I can - and do - spin up a new user whenever I need one, posting answers and gaining ...
Shog9's user avatar
  • 450k
47 votes
Accepted

Can we implement temporary automatic comment ban on 'x' number of validated rude comment flags?

This suggestion is coming up with increasing frequency in various forms; one of my colleagues expressed amazement this morning that we don't already do this - he'd spent the morning cleaning up after ...
Shog9's user avatar
  • 450k
44 votes
Accepted

A way for "new users" to ask about their post specifically

This feature is now live on all meta sites except the international sites (waiting on translations) and Meta Stack Overflow (to ensure that this doesn't cause a lot of undue disruptions on other sites ...
Robert Cartaino's user avatar
40 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

I have a question regarding this: What will the new user see when they are posting for the first time? If new users don't get any additional guidance from what they've already been getting, then ...
Bhargav Rao's user avatar
  • 10.8k
40 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

Three Two suggested improvements: For the experienced users: change "be sure to check out our Code of Conduct" to "remember to follow our Code of Conduct" or similar. "Check out" sounds like "hey, ...
Monica Cellio's user avatar
39 votes

Come Take a Look at our New Contributor Indicator!

This doesn't seem very helpful to me. I am glad that we have the first posts review queue, but I don't feel convinced that a new contributor indicator shown to all users will help with on-boarding new ...
user306255's user avatar
  • 1,184
36 votes

Are we creating divisions in our quest to make new users welcome?

There are 4 answers here currently, and each seems to address the fact that new users and established users must be considered separate groups because of their experience and knowledge of the site - ...
LinkBerest Left - SO is AI Now's user avatar
34 votes

We Really Love Hats!

I'll give my two cents on the ordinary Winterbash event since I didn't answer the previous discussion about it. While I won't tell Stack Exchange, or other users, what to do, I'd personally opt out ...
Shadow Wizard Love Zelda's user avatar
34 votes

What about the community is "toxic" to new users?

I would like to present a unbiased common man perspective here. I was a regular Stack Overflow consumer & attracted towards contribution by a friend's reputation ecstasy. That's the trigger. After ...
Arun Vinoth-Precog Tech - MVP's user avatar
32 votes

Introducing new user onboarding project

First off: thank you for doing this. I've often lamented the fact that new users don't know how to ask good questions because the platform doesn't tell them how to do it, and I'm delighted that you're ...
Ryan M's user avatar
  • 27.8k

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible