6

No, this is not a good idea, for (at least) two reasons: question quality is a different metric from on-topic-ness. They are often correlated, but not the same thing. Questions can be badly formulated but not off-topic, or of great quality, but still very much off-topic. We have plenty of popular questions on Stack Overflow that are closed as off-topic, ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible