Skip to main content
replaced http://meta.stackexchange.com/ with https://meta.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

I found this questionthis question here on Meta from 2009, and it was closed recently as a duplicate of a question that was posted much later!

Why is that? It's not just that older questions can't be duplicates of newer questions, but I also wonder why people dug up this old one and started to cast close votes on it all of a sudden; it hadn't had any activity for years.

Not that I have much reason to have it reopened or to have the newer one closed, but I'm just curious.

Edit:
Given the responses, this question might be better off as a feature request. So here goes:

Suggestion

Change the text in the "Closed" notification from "This question covers exactly the same content as earlier questions on this topic" to "other questions".

I found this question here on Meta from 2009, and it was closed recently as a duplicate of a question that was posted much later!

Why is that? It's not just that older questions can't be duplicates of newer questions, but I also wonder why people dug up this old one and started to cast close votes on it all of a sudden; it hadn't had any activity for years.

Not that I have much reason to have it reopened or to have the newer one closed, but I'm just curious.

Edit:
Given the responses, this question might be better off as a feature request. So here goes:

Suggestion

Change the text in the "Closed" notification from "This question covers exactly the same content as earlier questions on this topic" to "other questions".

I found this question here on Meta from 2009, and it was closed recently as a duplicate of a question that was posted much later!

Why is that? It's not just that older questions can't be duplicates of newer questions, but I also wonder why people dug up this old one and started to cast close votes on it all of a sudden; it hadn't had any activity for years.

Not that I have much reason to have it reopened or to have the newer one closed, but I'm just curious.

Edit:
Given the responses, this question might be better off as a feature request. So here goes:

Suggestion

Change the text in the "Closed" notification from "This question covers exactly the same content as earlier questions on this topic" to "other questions".

Migration of MSO links to MSE links
Source Link

I found this questionthis question here on Meta from 2009, and it was closed recently as a duplicate of a question that was posted much later!

Why is that? It's not just that older questions can't be duplicates of newer questions, but I also wonder why people dug up this old one and started to cast close votes on it all of a sudden; it hadn't had any activity for years.

Not that I have much reason to have it reopened or to have the newer one closed, but I'm just curious.

Edit:
Given the responses, this question might be better off as a feature request. So here goes:

Suggestion

Change the text in the "Closed" notification from "This question covers exactly the same content as earlier questions on this topic" to "other questions".

I found this question here on Meta from 2009, and it was closed recently as a duplicate of a question that was posted much later!

Why is that? It's not just that older questions can't be duplicates of newer questions, but I also wonder why people dug up this old one and started to cast close votes on it all of a sudden; it hadn't had any activity for years.

Not that I have much reason to have it reopened or to have the newer one closed, but I'm just curious.

Edit:
Given the responses, this question might be better off as a feature request. So here goes:

Suggestion

Change the text in the "Closed" notification from "This question covers exactly the same content as earlier questions on this topic" to "other questions".

I found this question here on Meta from 2009, and it was closed recently as a duplicate of a question that was posted much later!

Why is that? It's not just that older questions can't be duplicates of newer questions, but I also wonder why people dug up this old one and started to cast close votes on it all of a sudden; it hadn't had any activity for years.

Not that I have much reason to have it reopened or to have the newer one closed, but I'm just curious.

Edit:
Given the responses, this question might be better off as a feature request. So here goes:

Suggestion

Change the text in the "Closed" notification from "This question covers exactly the same content as earlier questions on this topic" to "other questions".

edited tags
Link
animuson StaffMod
  • 190.4k
  • 38
  • 584
  • 854
Changed it into a feature request
Source Link
Mr Lister
  • 4.2k
  • 3
  • 21
  • 34
Loading
Source Link
Mr Lister
  • 4.2k
  • 3
  • 21
  • 34
Loading