I agree with you. I have found these reasons:
ProsCons:
- Allows the more experienced users on Meta and other sites to voice their opinions on more matters than are currently possible
- Allows the community to show greater appreciation to the well-thought answers and questions
- Allows the larger members of the community to have a slightly larger voice than the people who just log on once or twice a week
ConsPros:
- If SO does this to upvotes, they would have to alter thier rep systems, auto-flag systems(for 'power-upvotes' (can't remember the term))
- They would most likely make these harder to get as you go on, and more people would go on these sites more and more, creating addictions (or furthering current ones)
This is community wiki, so add what you think this would do to the community.