Skip to main content
Notice removed Draw attention by sp00m
Bounty Ended with Rachel's answer chosen by sp00m
Notice added Draw attention by sp00m
Bounty Started worth 150 reputation by sp00m
edited title
Link
sp00m
  • 138
  • 11

How do the favorite/ignored tags filterinfluence the main questions feed?

added 149 characters in body
Source Link
sp00m
  • 138
  • 11

If you've just created a new Stack Overflow account, the main feed contains all the available questions: there's no filter applied on it. Then, you can add your Favorite Tags and your Ignored Tags. Since I find the feed is particularly accurate and well filtered, I wonder:

  1. How do the favorite tags influence the feed? I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but it would have been too restrictive. The idea is not "the more you tag the more you see" but rather "the more you tag the less you see". Stack Overflow implemented it that way: there are still displayed questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?

  2. How do the ignored tags influence the feed? It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?

  3. What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag: does the question get displayed or not? It seems also to depend on criteria: which ones?


1) How do the favorite tags influence the feed?

I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but it would have been too restrictive. The idea is not "the more you tag the more you see" but rather "the more you tag the less you see". In other words, if there are 100 questions at the beginning:

  • what should not be: 1 tag > 10 questions, 2 tags > 20 questions...
  • what should be: 1 tag > 90 questions, 2 tags > 80 questions...

Stack Overflow implemented it the right way: there are still displayed questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?


2) How do the ignored tags influence the feed?

It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?


3) What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag?

Does the question get displayed or not? It seems also that it depends on criteria, but which ones?

If you've just created a new Stack Overflow account, the main feed contains all the available questions: there's no filter applied on it. Then, you can add your Favorite Tags and your Ignored Tags. Since I find the feed is particularly accurate and well filtered, I wonder:

  1. How do the favorite tags influence the feed? I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but it would have been too restrictive. The idea is not "the more you tag the more you see" but rather "the more you tag the less you see". Stack Overflow implemented it that way: there are still displayed questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?

  2. How do the ignored tags influence the feed? It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?

  3. What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag: does the question get displayed or not? It seems also to depend on criteria: which ones?

If you've just created a new Stack Overflow account, the main feed contains all the available questions: there's no filter applied on it. Then, you can add your Favorite Tags and your Ignored Tags. Since I find the feed is particularly accurate and well filtered, I wonder:


1) How do the favorite tags influence the feed?

I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but it would have been too restrictive. The idea is not "the more you tag the more you see" but rather "the more you tag the less you see". In other words, if there are 100 questions at the beginning:

  • what should not be: 1 tag > 10 questions, 2 tags > 20 questions...
  • what should be: 1 tag > 90 questions, 2 tags > 80 questions...

Stack Overflow implemented it the right way: there are still displayed questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?


2) How do the ignored tags influence the feed?

It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?


3) What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag?

Does the question get displayed or not? It seems also that it depends on criteria, but which ones?

added 149 characters in body
Source Link
sp00m
  • 138
  • 11

If you've just created a new Stack Overflow account, the main feed contains all the available questions: there's no filter applied on it. Then, you can add your Favorite Tags and your Ignored Tags. Since I find the feed is particularly accurate and well filtered, I wonder:

  1. How do the favorite tags influence the feed? I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but it would have been too restrictive. The idea is not "the more you tag the more you see" but rather "the more you tag the less you see". Stack Overflow implemented it otherwisethat way: there are still displayed questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?

  2. How do the ignored tags influence the feed? It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?

  3. What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag: does the question get displayed or not? It seems also to depend on criteria: which ones?

If you've just created a new Stack Overflow account, the main feed contains all the available questions: there's no filter applied on it. Then, you can add your Favorite Tags and your Ignored Tags. Since I find the feed is particularly accurate and well filtered, I wonder:

  1. How do the favorite tags influence the feed? I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but Stack Overflow implemented it otherwise: there are still questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?

  2. How do the ignored tags influence the feed? It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?

  3. What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag: does the question get displayed or not? It seems also to depend on criteria: which ones?

If you've just created a new Stack Overflow account, the main feed contains all the available questions: there's no filter applied on it. Then, you can add your Favorite Tags and your Ignored Tags. Since I find the feed is particularly accurate and well filtered, I wonder:

  1. How do the favorite tags influence the feed? I would have said that when the first favorite tag has been entered, only questions that are linked to that tag get displayed, but it would have been too restrictive. The idea is not "the more you tag the more you see" but rather "the more you tag the less you see". Stack Overflow implemented it that way: there are still displayed questions that aren't tagged with any of my favorite tags, but these questions are (usually) still interesting to me. How do they get chosen? Why these ones and not others? Are there relations between tags (i.e. not only synonyms but also linked tags)? If yes, how are they set? Collaboratively or by an admin (or both)?

  2. How do the ignored tags influence the feed? It seems to be more understandable, since you could think that questions tagged with any of the tags I ignored won't be ever displayed. But once again, I already saw displayed questions that were tagged with one of my ignored tags. Why? How have they been chosen?

  3. What choice has been made when a question is tagged with a favorite tag AND an ignored tag: does the question get displayed or not? It seems also to depend on criteria: which ones?

added 68 characters in body
Source Link
sp00m
  • 138
  • 11
Loading
Source Link
sp00m
  • 138
  • 11
Loading