Skip to main content
Rollback to Revision 7
Source Link
Luuklag
  • 36.2k
  • 7
  • 75
  • 176
  1. The Community user has received a "bot" badgelabel, similar to how I have a "staff" badgelabel and mods have a "mod" badgelabel. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" taglabel to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

  1. The Community user has received a "bot" badge, similar to how I have a "staff" badge and mods have a "mod" badge. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" tag to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

  1. The Community user has received a "bot" label, similar to how I have a "staff" label and mods have a "mod" label. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" label to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

Rollback to Revision 6 - Labels vs badges is a less important debate than testing rollbacks
Source Link
rla4 Staff
  • 1.5k
  • 13
  • 14
  1. The Community user has received a "bot" labelbadge, similar to how I have a "staff" labelbadge and mods have a "mod" labelbadge. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" labeltag to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

  1. The Community user has received a "bot" label, similar to how I have a "staff" label and mods have a "mod" label. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" label to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

  1. The Community user has received a "bot" badge, similar to how I have a "staff" badge and mods have a "mod" badge. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" tag to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

Reworded per https://meta.stackexchange.com/q/369310
Source Link
bad_coder
  • 28k
  • 8
  • 51
  • 132
  1. The Community user has received a "bot" badgelabel, similar to how I have a "staff" badgelabel and mods have a "mod" badgelabel. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" taglabel to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

  1. The Community user has received a "bot" badge, similar to how I have a "staff" badge and mods have a "mod" badge. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" tag to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

  1. The Community user has received a "bot" label, similar to how I have a "staff" label and mods have a "mod" label. This now shows up next to the name of the Community user.

  2. Reviewers will have the option to submit their feedback as either the Community user or as themselves.

  3. Reviewers will be able to create their own custom feedback through the Share Feedback modal. This custom feedback can only be shared as the reviewer themself, not the Community user.

  4. Users who try to respond to the Community bot's posts will be informed, additionally, that they are replying to an unmonitored bot account (exact wording TBD).

  5. Mods will be able to delete Community bot comments, and other users will be able to flag the comments as "No longer needed."

  6. We're revisiting the text of some of the feedback strings to try to make it as general as possible.

  1. Creating blanket community-specific feedback options - this is a fairly large undertaking that we're not flat-out declining, we just don't have the resources to get to it right now.

  2. Creating a specific "Review" bot - like the item above, this is a big undertaking, and as most of the issues can be resolved by adding a "bot" label to Community, we're going with that solution instead.

  3. Reviewers can't undo feedback that they've sent in error - This will be able to be handled by flagging the comment as "no longer needed," so we're not going to create a specific way to undo feedback.

  4. The Community bot is only anonymous through obscurity (can be determined by looking at the post timeline) - We're willing to address this in the future if it seems like revenge downvoting is becoming a problem in this context, but we think that it's obscured enough right now that folks having their posts reviewed in these queues won't typically go searching for this information.

update with link to Community bot label post
Source Link
Loading
link to other post
Source Link
Loading
edited tags
Link
Luuklag
  • 36.2k
  • 7
  • 75
  • 176
Loading
added 1 character in body
Source Link
bad_coder
  • 28k
  • 8
  • 51
  • 132
Loading
edited tags
Link
bobble
  • 8.3k
  • 4
  • 21
  • 62
Loading
Source Link
Loading