Skip to main content
previous graphics provided were inaccurate
Source Link
paulusm
  • 441
  • 2
  • 8

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The resultsmean diff for questions was 0.92, whereas for answers it was 0.94 (they are pretty different — I'mboth close to 1 as many posts are not familiar enough with SOedited). Moreover 35% of questions have been edited compared to know why it's come out like thisonly 20% of answers. There could well be a very simple reason — or a basic processing error on my part! — to explain it

Here are histograms for postsThe shape of editing is different between the two, however, with 2 orquestions getting more smaller edits:

Questions than answers (questions in red, answers blue dashed):

Question Diffs

Answers:density plots of questions (red) and answer (blue dashed) diffs below 1

Answer Diffs I'm interested in the differences in edits between questions and answers

Disclosure: This is part of my PhD research — answers or useful comments will be acknowledged.

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The results are pretty different — I'm not familiar enough with SO to know why it's come out like this. There could well be a very simple reason — or a basic processing error on my part! — to explain it

Here are histograms for posts with 2 or more edits:

Questions:

Question Diffs

Answers:

Answer Diffs

Disclosure: This is part of my PhD research — answers or useful comments will be acknowledged.

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The mean diff for questions was 0.92, whereas for answers it was 0.94 (they are both close to 1 as many posts are not edited). Moreover 35% of questions have been edited compared to only 20% of answers.

The shape of editing is different between the two, however, with questions getting more smaller edits than answers (questions in red, answers blue dashed):

density plots of questions (red) and answer (blue dashed) diffs below 1

I'm interested in the differences in edits between questions and answers

Disclosure: This is part of my PhD research — answers or useful comments will be acknowledged.

Fix trivial typos
Source Link
Jonathan Leffler
  • 11.2k
  • 1
  • 23
  • 62

Why are questions edited more thorouglythoroughly than answers?

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The results are pretty different - I'm not familiar enough with SO to know why it's come out like this. There could well be a very simple reason - or a basic processing error on my part! - to explain it

Here are histograms for posts with 2 or more edits:

Questions:

Question Diffs

Answers:

Answer Diffs

Disclosure: thisThis is part of my PhD research - answers or useful comments will be acknowledged.

Why are questions edited more thorougly than answers?

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The results are pretty different - I'm not familiar enough with SO to know why it's come out like this. There could well be a very simple reason - or a basic processing error on my part! - to explain it

Here are histograms for posts with 2 or more edits:

Questions:

Question Diffs

Answers:

Answer Diffs

Disclosure: this is part of my PhD research - answers or useful comments will be acknowledged

Why are questions edited more thoroughly than answers?

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The results are pretty different I'm not familiar enough with SO to know why it's come out like this. There could well be a very simple reason or a basic processing error on my part! to explain it

Here are histograms for posts with 2 or more edits:

Questions:

Question Diffs

Answers:

Answer Diffs

Disclosure: This is part of my PhD research answers or useful comments will be acknowledged.

Source Link
paulusm
  • 441
  • 2
  • 8

Why are questions edited more thorougly than answers?

I used the PostHistory table and ran a Python diff ratio using the first and last edits for both questions and answers. This is supposed to give 1 if the posts are identical and 0 if there are no similarities found.

The results are pretty different - I'm not familiar enough with SO to know why it's come out like this. There could well be a very simple reason - or a basic processing error on my part! - to explain it

Here are histograms for posts with 2 or more edits:

Questions:

Question Diffs

Answers:

Answer Diffs

Disclosure: this is part of my PhD research - answers or useful comments will be acknowledged