Skip to main content
Post Deleted by CommunityBot
Post Locked by CommunityBot
Post Migrated Away to programmers.meta.stackexchange.com by Laura
Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by Laura
Post Reopened by Laura
Post Closed as "Duplicate" by reneMod, gnat, Martijn Pieters, Shadow Wizard discussion
Made the question more generic/more widely applicable by removing specific example
Source Link
Jonny
  • 101
  • 3

I recently asked [this question][1]a question (edited: I've removed the link because I would like an answer that is not specific to only one question). It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I heavehave learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.

Edit/clarification: I was wondering what to do in the general case if I have any question that gets put On Hold, not what specifically what to do to clean up the linked question (I almost didn't link to it to emphasise that point). I wanted to ask because I could not find any guidance on other meta questions. [1]: http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/264226/advantages-of-unmanaged-code

I recently asked [this question][1]. It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I heave learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.

Edit/clarification: I was wondering what to do in the general case if I have any question that gets put On Hold, not what specifically what to do to clean up the linked question (I almost didn't link to it to emphasise that point). I wanted to ask because I could not find any guidance on other meta questions. [1]: http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/264226/advantages-of-unmanaged-code

I recently asked a question (edited: I've removed the link because I would like an answer that is not specific to only one question). It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I have learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.

added 318 characters in body
Source Link
Jonny
  • 101
  • 3

I recently asked this question[this question][1]. It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I heave learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.

Edit/clarification: I was wondering what to do in the general case if I have any question that gets put On Hold, not what specifically what to do to clean up the linked question (I almost didn't link to it to emphasise that point). I wanted to ask because I could not find any guidance on other meta questions. [1]: http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/264226/advantages-of-unmanaged-code

I recently asked this question. It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I heave learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.

I recently asked [this question][1]. It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I heave learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.

Edit/clarification: I was wondering what to do in the general case if I have any question that gets put On Hold, not what specifically what to do to clean up the linked question (I almost didn't link to it to emphasise that point). I wanted to ask because I could not find any guidance on other meta questions. [1]: http://programmers.stackexchange.com/questions/264226/advantages-of-unmanaged-code

Source Link
Jonny
  • 101
  • 3

How to respond to my question being on hold

I recently asked this question. It has been placed on hold as too broad - which is fine, I think the question in its current form is too broad and I am not appealing against the decision.

What I want to know now is what do I do next? Is it my duty (maybe a too strong word) as a stack-exchanger to clean up the question and leave it as a non-closed question so that others who have the same question can get an answer? Shall I just let it go from On Hold to Closed? Are there any reasons why it would be bad for me to have a question Closed (rep loss, less likely to get good answers in the future, ...)?

I am happy that I have an answer. I heave learnt something, I have been forced to rethink some concepts and to get a more rigorous understanding of a few terms. I just want to make sure that I am giving back to the community as much as I am taking.