9

This question seems to be a duplicate of this one, but it is answered, and the possible original isn't. In this case, should the answered question be flagged for closure as a duplicate, or should the older question?

18

Flag the question that has the least amount of valuable information (between the question and answers combined) as a duplicate of the question with the most valuable information, regardless of when they were posted.

If the two questions both have lots of (different) valuable information then flag the post and ask a mod to merge them; they'll decide on their own which should be merged into which.

Note that you also can't close a post as a duplicate unless the canonical question has an answer (unless they were both posted by the same user), so in this particular case there isn't even a choice; close the one without an answer.

  • 6
    I reasonably often see posts closed as duplicates that, as it happens, are significantly more valuable than the 'canonical' versions that remain open (often they are more highly viewed, better written, and have the best of the answers that the two questions have). I'd always assumed that things ended up this way because older questions couldn't be closed as dupes of newer, but apparently not. Your post raises an interesting idea: perhaps I should try flagging those posts for moderator attention recommending that they swap which question is closed. – Mark Amery Sep 20 '13 at 15:35
  • 1
    @MarkAmery Sure; you're more than welcome to do that. – Servy Sep 20 '13 at 15:39

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .