46

Even though I would like so, I refrain from adding a flair link on my personal web site because solely serving the PNG flair image file already places a third party prov cookie on the computer of my web site visitors. (I added my flair here without any link for easy testing purposes.)

flair

I really cannot see the necessity for this prov cookie which expires only on Fri 01 Jan 2055 01:00:00 CET. Moreover, as a personal web site owner it burdens me with an additional legal liability to comply with EU cookie legislation.

Can I have my flair without the cookie, please?

10
+50

Thanks for the request, Serge. This is implemented (or de-implemented I guess?) now. It wasn't our intention to bake a prov cookie on this route so we won't anymore. This should be fixed for both network and site specific flair.

  • 4
    One of those small changes with big impact. Thanks!! – Shadow Jun 5 '18 at 14:33
-10

While this is not the best place to ask this question, I will still try to give complete answer:

For a shorthand answer: No, unless you download it on your own.

Technical side:

client-side solutions

You cannot hotlink this image in html document without letting execution of external scripts (which in this case would produce third party cookies).

From what I know, there is no cross-browser mechanism (or actually there is probably no such mechanism at all) that could allow download it client-side, while it has Access-Control-Allow-Origin property set not to allow cross-downloading of resources, and such it is in case of stackexchange server policy.

server-side solutions

You CAN however manually download the file and store it on your server under specific filename and then use it as a regular image. You can use various server-side solutions to download it at some cirumstances e.g. CRON, php script downloading the image at given conditions (e.g. periodically check if flair has changed, and overwrite it's copy if so), etc.

Legal side:

usage

Here things get a little tricky. While this flair is an image in technical terms, I believe this does not fall under art copyright, but most legislations are unclear on this all over the world. There are really many logotypes in this flair, it also contains user photo which basically makes it really messy in terms of being used by user it is attached to. I believe court would never find a person using this kind of flair guilty, but one cannot be certain of this. Note that there is no specified policy on flairs in stackexchange legal documents.

client-side solutions

Hotlinking requires you to put cookie consent box within EU, as it WILL produce third party cookies.

What comes to downloading it as data client-side, if you were able to do it from your script client-side while all mechanisms concerning this DENY doing so, this could really put you in risky situation, as this script would be most probably considered equally as computer virus in terms of law, so making a script like this, or even putting it on your site while you know how it works could in worst case get you to jail.

server-side solutions

Downloading it manually on your own or by server-side script seems to be the safest way in terms of doing so. If only you are allowed to use it, there should be no problem with this.

  • 5
    While this is not the best place to ask this question ... Why not? – rene Jun 3 '18 at 18:34
  • 2
    @rene probably the answer author is not familiar with Meta Stack Exchange and/or global flair. – Shadow Jun 3 '18 at 19:31
  • This answer is full of unrelated comments and just plain wrong. I suggest to delete it since it has not given a proper answer to the question. – Patrick Hofman Jun 3 '18 at 21:02
  • And I hope you are a lawyer given you are giving legal advice here. – Patrick Hofman Jun 3 '18 at 21:04
  • 5
    This is the perfect place to ask such questions, as it is where the community discusses such things in a way that the developers can engage – Lonely Neuron Jun 3 '18 at 21:29
  • 6
    The question is not asking "what are the ways I can act on my own to show a random image from a random website", but "can SE change its site code to stop serving cookies with flair?" It is not a web development question (which would be off-topic), but a feature request for the developers of this network. – Nathan Tuggy Jun 3 '18 at 23:43

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .