Questions tagged [convert-to-comment]
For questions related to converting answers to comments.
102
questions
17
votes
0
answers
194
views
Able to post comments on comment-locked questions by triggering the trivial answer conversion to comment script
The system has a feature where if one posts an answer with very short text and an internal link to another post on the site, it will not be posted as an answer, but instead as a comment, telling the ...
13
votes
0
answers
80
views
Improve workflow for converting a deleted answer into a comment
I was trying to convert a deleted answer to a comment via the moderator menu for the post. That didn't work, I get a message
answer deleted; can't be converted to comment
Because a (non-deleted) ...
GlorfindelMod
- 239k
9
votes
1
answer
73
views
Confusing "The Question" text in "convert answer to comment" dialog box
As a first-time mod in an SE site, I was confused by the extra text "The Question" that shows up after the question ID in the text field of the dialog to convert an answer into a comment:
...
- 441
13
votes
0
answers
53
views
Edited answer converted to a comment produces "no edit history found for this comment" message
When an edited answer is converted into a comment, the comment will get the familiar pencil icon to indicate it has been edited, but if you click on it (an option only available to ♦ moderators),...
GlorfindelMod
- 239k
4
votes
0
answers
46
views
Wrong favicon on error page when trying to convert a deleted answer into a comment
If you are trying to convert a deleted answer into a comment, you will be redirected to error page.
As you can see, this page shows SOen favicon, but should use SOru icon.
8
votes
0
answers
116
views
Difficult to lose the "converted to a comment" status message
If an answer is converted to a comment and then subsequently undeleted, and then deleted again (without being converted to a comment), the message beneath the post still reads:
If the answer is then ...
- 3,935
-2
votes
1
answer
236
views
How can a moderator prevent their answer from being automatically converted to a comment on meta site?
As discussed in this meta thread, I had some difficulty posting a valid answer to an undelete request on the open data meta site.
My question is, as a mod of the site, and the fact that it is the ...
- 231
-8
votes
2
answers
205
views
Allow users with less than 50 rep to comment if they've already commented [duplicate]
The title of my question could look weird at the first sight, but I will explain it to you.
Recently, I’ve seen a user that posted an answer to an old question, but their answer was actually a ...
- 55.1k
3
votes
0
answers
44
views
Hide 'convert to comment' from the mod menu on deleted answers
♦ moderators can convert answers to comments. Converting a deleted answer to a comment is not possible; you'll get a message
answer deleted; can't be converted to comment
This makes sense; ...
GlorfindelMod
- 239k
4
votes
0
answers
101
views
Inconsistent presentation of "Convert to comment" option
I have seen a couple of these situations, today, where I have a "bad" answer ("bad" for whatever reason), that has been flagged, which would serve better as a comment. However, on the mod flag page ...
- 3,935
6
votes
1
answer
24
views
Prevent LQP review comments being moved when answer is converted to comment
Something I've noticed on several sites recently is that when a moderator converts a non-answer to a comment the automatic comments from the low quality posts review are moved along with it. The ...
- 6,228
-10
votes
2
answers
160
views
How can I prevent my "trivial" answer from being converted to a comment? [duplicate]
Now that the maximum tag length has been increased to 35, I've been spending some time browsing older retag requests to see which ones can now be completed.
On one such request, I tried posting the ...
- 14.6k
13
votes
1
answer
154
views
Post undeleted and converted to comment still shows as being deleted from review
I found this answer (only visible to 10k+ users on SFF, sorry) which had been deleted from review some hours ago but also flagged for conversion to a comment. I undeleted it and converted it to a ...
- 28.1k
10
votes
2
answers
179
views
Posting free-form comments is possible without having enough reputation
The current implementation of Stack Exchange allows us to comment on a particular question without even having enough reputation.
This can be done by exploiting the autocomment feature of Stack ...
- 139
4
votes
0
answers
49
views
Add visual indication that a comment was originally posted as an answer
Inspired by How did this person who has 1 rep comment on a question? and this comment, I think that adding a visual indication when a comment was actually an answer that was converted to comment by a ...
6
votes
1
answer
162
views
How did this person who has 1 rep comment on a question? [duplicate]
So here is their profile.
And here is the question.
How did the person in question, who has 1 rep, comment on a question?
- 861
8
votes
0
answers
78
views
Allow moderators to convert non-answers to comments on other answers from within the flag queue
The "convert to comment" tool available from the "mod" link underneath an answer allows moderators to specify the URL or ID of the post that should be the parent of the newly converted comment, as ...
- 3,705
7
votes
3
answers
198
views
Should I flag a comment if it is posted by someone who has only 1 rep?
In order to post comments a user must first earn at least 50 rep
Users with at least 50 reputation may comment on any post. (There is no reputation requirement to post comments on MSO only; doing ...
2
votes
2
answers
116
views
Why was a convert-answer-to-comment request turned down (at cost of -2 rep point for me)?
I am just wondering. I have a quite specialization in some context. After I give the answer, sometimes the asker have made it through, but it seems to take a little closer step.
While I didn't have ...
- 159
1
vote
1
answer
74
views
Why did my comment on an answer-converted-to-comment vanish into the void?
I've posted a comment to an answer from a new user, which was later converted to a comment, and now my comment is completely gone (doesn't even show in all-actions), and the answer-now-comment from ...
- 1,278
5
votes
1
answer
69
views
Link malformed in automatically converted answer to trivial comment
I'm not sure if this is a problem at all as this is the first time I'm posting a link (as I don't have enough rep to post comments) but my answer which points to an answer was automatically converted ...
- 153
1
vote
0
answers
21
views
The date is incorrectly truncated if the action was conversion to comment
Just noticed in this deleted answer.
The date "X mins/hours/whatever ago" should be fully moved to the new line.
- 34.1k
3
votes
1
answer
96
views
Don't update a comment converted from an answer when the deleted answer is edited
I converted an answer to a comment because it was just a question for the OP. The original answer was the following:
What happens if you would use a page callback like 'drupal_get_form' instead of '...
- 66.6k
7
votes
0
answers
45
views
Notifications vanish when answer is converted to comment
I noticed a "bug" (or maybe a conceptual shortcoming, but an important one) with converting answers to comments today.
Steps to reproduce:
User A answers a question.
User B comments on the answer ...
- 5,044
5
votes
0
answers
38
views
Cannot convert poorly formed answer into comment [duplicate]
I'm trying to convert an answer into a comment, but the system keeps rejecting my conversion with an irrelevant reason:
Well, I guess the message is true, but not particularly relevant in this ...
- 10.2k
3
votes
0
answers
53
views
Old answers converted to comments shouldn't show up as new messages in the global inbox
A comment from 2009 has just shown up at the top of my inbox. Initially it showed as one minute old, a few minutes later it's showing 4 minutes ago, so the time error appears to be dynamic not static....
4
votes
1
answer
78
views
How to delete post which is converted to a comment?
I add answer to question on gis.stackexchange.com but someone convert my answer to comment and the after I realize my answer was incorrect and I want to delete it but it is not posible now. So, is ...
- 41
22
votes
2
answers
240
views
Convert link only answers into comment instead of deleting them
While reviewing "Low Quality Posts", often I used to see answers in 2 categories
Answers referring to a 3rd party site or other questions in Stack Exchange.
Answers referring some sort of suggestions ...
- 3,707
-8
votes
1
answer
192
views
Questions with *many* answers, *most* of which clearly don’t answer the question asked
Sometimes someone will ask a question and then a bunch of people will post answers which clearly show that they did not read the entire question and/or ignored some important parts of it. For example, ...
- 1,163
1
vote
0
answers
44
views
Comment upvotes not carried over when converting answer to comment [duplicate]
I know it's already been covered that Answer upvotes are not the same as Comment upvotes, but suppose the following situation occurs:
Useful answer that should have been a comment
- Useful comment ...
- 4,415
6
votes
0
answers
142
views
Convert code blocks to backtick syntax when converting answers to comments
If an answer has an indented code block, if it's converted to a comment, the formatting is ignored, leaving just plain text "code".
It would be better if the indented code was wrapped in backticks to ...
- 9,648
13
votes
0
answers
282
views
Stack Overflow calls my short answer "trivial"
I wrote a short answer today, and I was a bit miffed when Stack Overflow called it trivial and turned it into a comment.
I think it's fine to turn a short answer into a comment, but I think the ...
- 295
3
votes
1
answer
153
views
Comment on a question without 50 reputation points [duplicate]
Yesterday I wanted to comment on a question on Stack Overflow, but I don't have 50 reputation points. The question is that I referred in my answer to another Stack Overflow question, and my ...
- 133
1
vote
1
answer
135
views
How does Stack Exchange decide if an answer is trivial enough to make it a comment? [duplicate]
I just wrote an answer to a question and it was automatically converted to a comment for being 'trivial'. What are the criteria of a trivial answer?
The answer was posted here but has since been ...
- 223
13
votes
2
answers
293
views
Why was a correct answer deleted and converted to a comment? [duplicate]
Please refer to the following question (on SO):
How to list all the files changed by a perforce change list
One of the answers to the question was deleted and converted to a comment:
Although many ...
- 3,675
3
votes
2
answers
154
views
Is "This should be a Comment" feature removed?
My question is different from Should there be a policy about 'One-Link-Only-Answers'?
even if you see above question comment Marc has commented "if the link is only to a SE post, it is automatically ...
- 577
11
votes
1
answer
177
views
Answers automatically converted to comments — a few suggestions
Today I joined the long list of contributors who came here wondering why their answers had been inexplicably posted as comments. I'm not going to bother arguing that this feature belongs on the scrap ...
- 347
-1
votes
1
answer
114
views
My answer to a question keeps being posted as comment [duplicate]
I was trying to post an answer to this question:
a: visited img { display: none; }
But for some reason, my answer was added to the comments section instead. This is what I was trying to post (at ...
- 347
-6
votes
4
answers
127
views
Answer converted to a comment [duplicate]
Today this happened to me. I was trying to answer a question and provided a link that can help the OP in solving the question. Why did the system converted it to a comment?
How come it identifies one ...
- 895
35
votes
2
answers
411
views
Please change the guidance for "convert to comment" to emphasize that this should only be used for comments posted as answers
Moderators have long had access to a tool for converting answers into comments. The guidance for this tool reads as follows:
Answers should be converted to comments when they contain useful ...
- 438k
5
votes
1
answer
136
views
Transform answer to comment [duplicate]
The review queue shows a lot of comments that were posted as an answer. The review possibilites only allow to keep the "answer" or flag it (which will usually result in a deletion).
Most of these "...
- 263
3
votes
1
answer
58
views
Answer converted to comment, but answer not deleted
This answer seems to be converted to a comment, since the user does not have enough reputation to comment on his own.
The question would be is why wasn't the answer removed?
- 1,126
5
votes
0
answers
41
views
"Convert to comment" option should be grayed out when not available
I just tried to convert a post to a comment via the moderator menu, only to be presented with a plain-text page saying
Comment must have a valid owner
Presumably this is because the owner was ...
- 10.3k
16
votes
4
answers
398
views
Are educational comments good?
Often, users leave educational comments on questions and answers.
What I mean are comments like:
"This answer should be a comment. Please consider reading this post about the difference."
&...
- 11.5k
1
vote
1
answer
86
views
Where does an answer that is flagged as NAA and converted to a comment go?
It says it was converted to a comment, but if you view the page, it doesn't show up as a comment....
model has_many users(of a specific role type)
But the answer has already been converted, and is ...
- 121
1
vote
2
answers
116
views
Allow moderators to convert answers containing multiple @-replies into comment(s)
A frequent occurrence, in my experience, is that someone who
does not understand the comment system, or
does not have enough reputation to post a comment, or
would have been able to comment due to ...
- 1,105
-23
votes
2
answers
140
views
High-rep users should be exempt from answer-to-comment autoconversion
Currently, a short, machine-identified-as-seemingly-low-quality answer is automatically converted to a comment on the question.
gbn has suggested in a comment that this be "weighted for, say, user ...
- 5,939
1
vote
3
answers
96
views
How to be brief without being trivial
I wanted to give a short answer to a question, by linking to my answer to a previous question. My answer was caught as "trivial" and converted to a comment.
When I want to give the same answer to ...
- 1,774
4
votes
0
answers
142
views
Trivial answer conversion [duplicate]
I've noticed that on some Stack Exchange sites (like Super User), if I post a short answer I get "Trivial answer automatically converted to comment". However, on other sites (like Android Enthusiasts) ...
- 151
1
vote
0
answers
100
views
"My answer was converted to a comment; see the faq", Okay, but what for?
This is the thread in question. I did some search in meta, and found this and this. In first of those cases the answer contains only external links, and second case, the answer was more like a ...
- 1,563