95
votes
Accepted
I feel that lately the answers to my questions on Stack Exchange are low quality
No, it's not you. This is just a natural consequence of Stack Overflow shifting the focus from a high-quality library of knowledge towards quantity, i.e. attracting as many users as possible while at ...
32
votes
Community should not autodownvote "low quality" autoflags cleared by edits
Update: August 15, 2019
The system no longer automatically downvotes posts as a result of automatic flags anymore.
Update: August 31, 2017
Internally, we discussed several ways to implement this, but ...
- 51.4k
30
votes
Let's Remove The Auto Downvote On Validated VLQ Flags (On Questions)
Since it's pretty much my fault that VLQ comes with an automatic downvote to begin with, I feel like I should weigh in on this.
I feel very strongly that we should not be removing posts we aren't even ...
- 445k
29
votes
I feel that lately the answers to my questions on Stack Exchange are low quality
I stopped asking questions a few years back on Stack Overflow because:
My questions were no longer "easy" since I could both research myself as well as I've become a much better engineer in the last ...
- 20.2k
26
votes
Accepted
Community downvotes posts that were just fixed
The system will now revoke the automatic downvote if, after the flag is marked Helpful, the post later gets an upvote.
Remember, the automatic downvote essentially exists because folks use this flag ...
- 445k
26
votes
Accepted
What did Stack Exchange/Overflow change in May 2016 that cut low-quality questions so dramatically on the flagship sites?
I'm afraid the explanation here is kinda boring.
There's a job that runs weekly which deletes any question more than 365 days old which...
has a score of 0 or less, or a score of 1 or less in ...
- 445k
23
votes
Reviewing the Stack Exchange Policy on Low-quality Contribution
and I have never violated the code of conduct (I have been called offensive words such as "troll" by some users, but I have never responded them with any offensive word) and any written ...
- 39.1k
22
votes
In the low-quality queue, make it more clear that the canned comments are just that
As a possible solution, I propose to do the following two things:
Add a description to No comment needed like:
This is a good choice if an existing comment already addresses the post’s issues.
...
- 28k
21
votes
Accepted
What exactly does a VLQ flag do?
The answer to this question has changed since this other answer was posted. Here's how things look in 2017:
Yes (mostly because as explained in point 3, there's no guarantee that the flag will do ...
- 2,120
21
votes
Remove VLQ as a flag option
On questions, it's a super-downvote if the question gets closed. This isn't terribly useful, except that some people use it instead of a downvote — hey, people, if you see a very low quality question, ...
21
votes
Accepted
I did not flag all these posts as Very Low Quality
This bug has now been fixed network wide. In a certain case of flagging logic, it was checking all flags instead of just your flags to see if you've already raised a flag. I've fixed the check and you ...
- 6,868
20
votes
Accepted
Can we retire the Reversal badge on main sites and keep it only for meta sites?
Disclaimer: I have the Reversal badge but only on a site meta.
Yes, let's get rid of it. Gold badges are generally intended to be awarded when someone does something great for the site. Many users ...
- 13.4k
20
votes
Can we retire the Reversal badge on main sites and keep it only for meta sites?
I'm very sorry to say but I disagree. Disclosure: I was the first to ever get this badge on Ask Ubuntu
And this is not because I was the first to obtain such a badge on Ask Ubuntu, but because of ...
- 2,258
20
votes
I feel that lately the answers to my questions on Stack Exchange are low quality
I've noticed this trend myself as well. However, some of that might be attributable to my questions leaning more on edge cases (i.e., long tail programming questions) that seems to arise with more ...
- 12.2k
19
votes
When confronted with spam in the LQP queue, should I press 'delete' or 'looks okay'?
When I encounter spam in the LQP queue, I go to the post and flag it as spam, as you do. Then I click Skip in the queue.
After several Looks OK reviews, a post is dropped from the queue, preventing ...
- 6,318
18
votes
Include the option to flag posts as spam in the Low Quality queue
Spam deserves its own special place in hell.
And the sooner it gets there, the better. It should always be possible to flag a post as spam — when reading it, from a review queue, preferably even from ...
- 4,656
17
votes
Do bad-quality questions on the front page actually impact the company?
There is probably negligible impact in the short-term, since the company's income is from showing advertisements, and the vast proportion of page views come from external search engines, not via the ...
- 5,882
16
votes
Allow posts older than 7 days to be flagged as VLQ
I think this is a good idea because,
Low quality things get missed the first time around, I have seen absolute garbage posts get left up for years and years.
The need to delete doesn't go away after ...
- 3,355
16
votes
Accepted
How can a low quality post can get more than 15 or 20 reviewers?
tl;dr: this appears to be happening because no one is reviewing the item in the Close Votes queue, and not enough people with close voting privileges are reviewing or voting to close the post.
When it ...
16
votes
Accepted
Could we talk about turd polishing better?
I'm not sure we can find a better metaphor. I do understand nobody likes their post being called a turd, but it's difficult to find something which is worth less than sand and still not belittling. ...
GlorfindelMod
- 247k
15
votes
Remove VLQ as a flag option
Couple of quick notes here since I'm sick and probably can't write a coherent essay on this:
Flag types exist to direct and differentiate folks' desire to see problems addressed
You look at a post and ...
- 445k
15
votes
Making a constructive workflow for new users who post "me too" [non-]answers
"Bumping" a question isn't really a workflow on Stack Exchange. Questions are still discoverable based on search, and we should be pushing users to search for questions and answers through ...
- 57.5k
14
votes
Accepted
Is it OK to remove my own low quality question with decent/good answers?
No. The system will actually prevent you from removing questions with at least one up-voted (i.e. helpful) answer. Habitually removing your posts may even flag that content for moderator attention.
...
- 111k
14
votes
Accepted
Low-quality answer auto-comments sound a little hard to new users
Your current suggestions aren't any friendlier to the people that get them, because they leave out the important instructions. All your suggestions will do is end up with someone who, at best, just ...
- 39.1k
14
votes
Is flagging too many posts to add the citation banner grounds for suspension?
Any problematic behaviour can, when repeated, lead to a suspension. It's not just limited to the ones explicitly listed in A Day in the Penalty Box.
If we think you are reachable, and the behavior is ...
GlorfindelMod
- 247k
14
votes
Accepted
What happens if I flag posts as "trash"?
You think you're being funny. Nice try. See, Stack Exchange thought about people like you:
As it turns out, "trash" isn't a long enough reason to raise a flag at the system-level. So... ...
- 26.3k
13
votes
Can I have some closed question data? What should I point Parsey McParseface at?
I recommend you take a look at one of my queries. Of all the queries I have created, I think that this one shows the most promise. (There are other places on the network I have mentioned this query, ...
- 48k
13
votes
Tell answer-author when the question is being voted to close
Can we extend that same feature/courtesy to authors when a question is being voted to close?
The idea sounds great, it sounds like trying to make the site nicer and solve the problem of people ...
- 39.1k
13
votes
Accepted
Does accepting an answer invalidate a Low Quality Post review task?
Yes, it does. Any post which is closed, deleted, locked, or accepted is considered ineligible for the Low Quality Posts queue. For answers, the deleted and closed status of the parent question are ...
- 189k
13
votes
I feel that lately the answers to my questions on Stack Exchange are low quality
While it's hard to argue about SO's quality decline and focus on quantity over quality, as is shown in @samcarter's answer, there're more factors at play than just quality decline.
Experienced users ...
- 10.2k
Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible